Sign in to save & sync
Sign in
Variations, Claims & Disputes — topic preview
Learn

Advanced

Variations, Claims & Disputes

Extra items, hindrance, EOT and resolving disputes on record

3 lessons · 32 min · 3 videos · 2 articles

Lessons

An extra item is work that was not part of the original Bill of Quantities (BOQ) or scope but becomes necessary during execution, such as an unforeseen rock excavation requirement or an additional drainage line demanded by a site condition not visible at tender stage. A change order, sometimes called a variation order, is the formal instrument by which the owner or the engineer-in-charge authorises a change to the original scope, whether an addition, omission or substitution, and fixes how it will be measured and paid. Almost every well-drafted contract contains a variation clause empowering the engineer-in-charge to order such changes up to a stated percentage of contract value without needing a fresh tender, since re-tendering every small change would be impractical.

The critical discipline here is sequencing: never execute extra or substituted work on a verbal instruction alone. The contractor should raise a written request seeking approval and an agreed rate before starting the extra item, and if site urgency genuinely forces work to start before formal approval, the instruction should still be confirmed in writing (even a site order slip) at the earliest opportunity, with photographs and measurements recorded at the time. Rates for extra items are usually derived first by reference to similar existing BOQ items, and only when no comparable item exists is a fresh rate analysis built up from current material, labour and equipment costs plus the contractor's agreed overhead and profit margin, which is where disagreements most often arise.

A frequent and costly mistake is a contractor executing substantial extra work based on an oral assurance from the site engineer or project manager, only to find the sanctioning authority later disputes the quantum or even the existence of the instruction, because the person who gave the verbal go-ahead lacked financial authority to commit the owner to it. Understanding who on the owner's side actually holds authority to approve what value of variation, as set out in the contract's delegation of powers, is essential before relying on any instruction as binding.

Beyond a certain percentage of contract value, cumulative variations may trigger a requirement for a fresh competent sanction or even a supplementary agreement, and persistent scope creep through many small, individually modest change orders can quietly push a project well beyond its originally approved cost, which is exactly the pattern that internal audit and vigilance reviews on government projects are trained to look for.

Rate source priority

Similar BOQ item first, fresh rate analysis second

Documentation

Written instruction, photographs and measurements at the time

Remember on site

  • Extra items are work outside the original BOQ/scope; change orders are the formal instrument authorising them
  • Never start extra or substituted work on a verbal instruction alone; get it in writing, even after the fact
  • Rates for extra items come first from similar BOQ items, then from a fresh rate analysis if none exists
  • Confirm who actually holds financial authority to sanction a variation before relying on an instruction

Check yourself

What is an 'extra item' in a construction contract?

What does a change order (variation order) formally do?

Why do contracts usually empower the engineer-in-charge to order variations up to a stated percentage without a fresh tender?

What should a contractor do before starting extra or substituted work?

How are rates for extra items typically determined first?

What risk arises when a contractor relies on a verbal instruction from a site engineer lacking financial authority?

What can trigger the need for a fresh competent sanction or supplementary agreement?

What pattern do internal audit and vigilance reviews on government projects often scrutinise?

What should be recorded at the time extra work is executed, even under urgency?

What happens when no comparable item exists in the BOQ for pricing an extra item?

Watch

Read further

© 2026 SiteMate. All rights reserved.